Permit/Deny Ziff Davis Enterprise
Advertisement
Advertisement
Wednesday, January 23, 2008 12:28 PM/EST

My New iPhone, My Disappearing Privacy

My loss of privacy all started at a company-sponsored health and wellness fair in October.

I got my blood pressure tested and my flu vaccine and I entered a drawing for an iPod Shuffle being given away by AC Transit. I occasionally take the transbay bus to work at the Ziff Davis Enterprise office at 2nd and Mission in downtown San Fran and I was mostly interested in getting the free four-ride passes the representative was handing out.

As it turned out, I won, and in the mail I received an out-dated, 1GB iPod. Well, to use it I had to get iTunes.

And after I got iTunes, I got an iTunes gift certificate for Christmas.

And after I loaded up my iPod with the great dance hits of the '80s my beloved Treo started having problems.

Readers of this blog know that when I personally bought my Treo 650 many years ago, I thought it was the best thing since sliced bread. Unfortunately, one too many drops along the way were making it impossible for callers to hear me, using either the handset or the wired headset. Since I refuse to use a Bluetooth (not for health reasons, I just can't stand the nerdiness/cost/short battery life. Besides, if I can't use my hand to hold the phone, then I'm probably not engaged in an activity where phone use is appropriate). headset, it seemed a new phone was in order.

Anyway, that led to a fateful hazing incident where the other labbies dared/taunted/hasseled me about getting an iPhone.

Now Andrew Garcia loves his iPhone despite initial go-to-market problems. I already had iTunes and was in love with my little iPod. So, with a need to get a new phone, I took the plunge and got an iPhone.

I won't regale you with the wonders of the iPhone. You've probably already seen other stories that specialize in that coverage.

It was a 15-minute process at the store to get my new iPhone, which as you may already know, is activated at home via iTunes.

I got the phone home, ripped off the cellophane covers, saved the beautiful box and started activating my phone.

Now I am one to read privacy and license agreements, or at least print them out and save them. By the time I was done, I had agreed to almost 40 pages of license and privacy notices. So somewhere in that mess I must have said, "Yes, it is OK to share my contact information from AT&T (my wireless service provider) with Apple." I know this because when I went to the Apple store the next day to get a case for my digital familiar the clerk had my e-mail address on her wireless checkout necklace before I could say "Mary had a little lamb."

"Would you like me to just email the receipt," she asked.

I was so filled with geeky wonder at the fantastic amount of database-coding-wired-and-wireless-infrastructure-that-must-be-necessary-to-make-this-work that I didn't even question that my e-mail address was showing up at a store where I had never provided it.

Don't get me wrong, I wouldn't want my transaction to be more difficult. I'm certainly not under the illusion that saving the environment was the motivation behind e-mailing my receipt instead of printing it on a piece of paper. (I was given a gigantic, double-walled plastic bag in the form of a backpack with the Apple logo on it to carry my 1.5-ounce case out of the store. The case box and Apple backpack were immediately trashed as I did a Charlie Bucket on the curb, anxious to get my iPhone into its new protective jacket.) I am concerned that WAY TOO MUCH personal information was used to cement my relation with Apple.

I dread going back to the 40-plus pages of legalese to which I agreed to find out where I said it was OK to share my personal information back and forth between AT&T and Apple. But that's where I need to go to find the answer to my questions and try to regain some of my personal privacy.

For more IT related content on the blogosphere, check out www.ithub.com

TrackBack

TrackBack

http://blogs.eweek.com/cgi-bin/mte/mt-tb.cgi/12546

Comments (5)

Dennis Sweet :

Concerning the posting "My New iPhone, My Disappearing Privacy":

The writer says that he has an iPod, uses iTunes, and most importantly, has purchased music from iTunes. Yet he feels that ATT "shared" his e-mail address with the Apple Retail Store.

His iTunes account user name is most probably his e-mail address. Is it really surprising that the iTunes Store shared his e-mail address with the Apple Retail Store? Does it make sense for Apple to keep the iTunes customer database isolated from its Apple Retail Store database?

I personally would have been surprised if the Apple Store didn't have access to my information if I had been doing business with Apple's iTunes Store.

Furthermore, in addition to the obvious drawbacks of "shared" information, sharing of "personal" information can lead to better service. Upon checkout, the system could suggest new items that fit my interests that I may not have noticed on this visit. Much like Amazon will suggest similar books to those that I have bought in the past.

Herman I May :

Ummm, you have it mostly incorrect. You admit in your post that you established an iTunes account when you received your "out-dated, 1GB iPod" an that you also redeemed "an iTunes gift certificate". In order to redeem a gift certificate and shop at the iTMS, one must create an AppleID account; an integral part of which is provision of a valid eMail address. Since activation of an iPhone also requires an AppleID account, it was you who provided Apple with your eMail address!

All this attempt to raise a mountain, when all that exists is a self-generated molehill.

Joe H :

Don't you think it more likely that Apple pulled your email from your iTunes registration rather than from AT&T?

Charley :

This is an important issue regarding privacy, but the rest of the article is dribble. By the way if you were going to just throw the bag in the trash why take it in the first place.

I hate to pile on, but the writer was so busy printing out 40 pages he (admittedly) may never read and tossing his gigantic double-walled plastic bag/backpack in the trash that he missed the obvious - the Apple logo on all the web pages he used to not only create his iTunes account (for his shuffle iPod) but to purchase his great dance hits of the 80's". To be amazed that Apple shares info from its on-line and physical store fronts is, honestly, amazing - why would you assume otherwise?

BTW, the shuffle iPod is a great iPod for small children/toddlers - my 4 year-old daughter has hers loaded up with all "her" music and she plays it through a Spongebob iPod speaker device[0] that runs on batteries (I wouldn't give her in-ear headphones at 4, and over the ear headphones are to bulky for her)...

[0] http://bp1.blogger.com/_eMGHAxSB62M/Ru_njE4YLAI/AAAAAAAABgo/cw3DqhIQW6w/s1600-h/p3176744reg.jpg

Post a Comment

 
 


Advertisement
Advertisement